Author Archive for Barry DukePage 2 of 24

Ex-Muslim writes handbook for young atheists

EVIDENCE that more and more young people are learning that they can live life untrammelled by mind-rotting religious beliefs emerges virtually every week in reports on falling church attendances, surveys showing religion heading for oblivion in many Western countries, and in books aimed at clearing paths to a more rational outlook on life.

The latest of these is The Young Atheist’s Handbook, written by former Muslim Alom Shaha, a physics teacher at a comprehensive school in London. When he is not teaching, he works as a film-maker, writer and science communicator.

Alom Shaha

Shaha grew up in a strict Bangladeshi Muslim community in South-East London in the 1970s and 80s. He was expected to go to mosque regularly and recite passages in Arabic from the Koran, without being told what they meant.

He spent his teenage years juggling two utterly different worlds: a chaotic, sometimes funny, sometimes tragic family life on a council estate, and that of a student at a privileged private school set amongst the idyllic green playing fields of Dulwich.

In a charming blend of memoir, philosophy, and science, Shaha explores the questions about faith and the afterlife that we all ponder. Through a series of loose “lessons”, he tells his own compelling story, drawing on the theories of some of history’s greatest thinkers and questioning the fallacies that have impeded humanity for centuries.

He recounts how his education and formative experiences led him to question how to live without being tied to what his parents, priests, or teachers told him to believe, and offers insights so that others may do the same.

Robin Ince, writer and comedian said of The Young Atheist’s Handbook:

A book that destroys the cliche of the atheist as joyless rationalist and shows the humanity, love, and concern that often lies behind godless thinking.

And atheist comedian Tim Minchin said:

More than just a great handbook, this is an honest and often very moving story about valuing truth over hope, even in the face of grief.

Shaha passionately believes that a largely white (and male) atheist movement has to do a great deal more to engage with non-believers in ethnic groups.

In the Guardian in 2010 he stated:

There are issues that black and Asian atheists face that white atheists do not, for example, greater pressure to adhere to the religion of the communities in which they live. Since first writing about my atheism in public, I have been contacted by a number of Asian people who don’t believe in God but feel they have to carry on the pretence of being a Muslim because they genuinely fear that the consequences of “coming out” would be unbearable. They fear being ostracised from their family and friends, and “not being able to get married”. Sure, there are some white people who might face these same issues, but I would suggest the problem is more widespread in, for example, some Muslim communities than in the typical readership of the Guardian.

Hat tip: Adam Tjaavk

Irish priests vow to defy confessional law

A POLL currently running on Irish Central indicates public support for Irish priests who say they will defy a new law forcing them to report details of sexual abuse revealed in the confessional box. The poll was prompted by a report that Ireland’s Justice Minister Alan Shatter is to introduce new legislation which will force the clergy to reveal all details disclosed in confession.

But priests have vowed to defy the law despite the threat of a 10-year jail sentence after the introduction of the mandatory reporting legislation.

The 800 strong Association of Catholic Priests has even said that its members will flout the Shatter law.

Spokesman Fr Sean McDonagh told the Irish Independent:

I certainly wouldn’t be willing to break the seal of confession for anyone – Alan Shatter particularly.

Auxiliary Bishop of Dublin Raymond Field said:

The seal of the confessional is inviolable as far as I am concerned, and that’s the end of the matter.

Under the new law, every person in the state is obliged to report suspected sexual abuse of children and vulnerable adults to police.

Minister Shatter said:

I would expect that if there was someone going to confession who was a serial sex abuser, I don’t know how anyone could live with their conscience if they didn’t refer that to the gardai (police).

McDonagh also told the Irish Independent that a New Zealand Columbian priest, Fr Francis Douglas, was tortured to death by the Japanese during World War Two because he refused to reveal information received in confession about the Filipino guerrillas.

He is held up to us as a model of how you deal with this extraordinary sacrament. You shouldn’t put into legislation something that cannot be enforced. It makes a mockery of the legislation. Confessions are held in private so that priests do not know who is in the confessional box.

I would question whether the mandatory reporting requirement will stop even one case of child sexual abuse.

In response, Minister Shatter again highlighted the failure of the Catholic Church authorities to act on warnings from victims – and the movement of priests accused of abuse from parish to parish.

Meanwhile, it is encouraging to note that a Facebook page, set up in support of Ray D’Arcy, the Irish radio presenter who accused the Roman Catholic Church of “fucking up” his country, is getting fantastic support. So far it has attracted over 3,200 “likes”.

UPDATE: Tonight the poll is running strongly AGAINST the priests’ stance, with 58 percent saying they support the new law!

Hey Catholics, leave those kids alone!

PUPILS at a south London Catholic state school have reacted angrily to an anti-gay petition they were urged to sign at the end of a presentation encouraging them to oppose the gay marriage,

The presentation, given to “draw attention” to the Coalition for Marriage’s campaign against the Government’s proposal to allow gay couples to marry in civil ceremonies, caused pupils to “bristle” with anger and some considered:

Buying gay pride badges to pin on our uniform and thought about staging a Stonewall coup by posting the ‘Some people are gay – get over it’ posters around school.

These were the words of sixth-form student Katherine, who, in an exclusive Pink News report, said:

In our assembly for the whole Sixth Form you could feel people bristling as she explained parts of the [Catholic Education Service] letter and encouraged us to sign the petition. She said things about gay marriage and civil partnerships being unnatural. It was just a really out-dated, misjudged and heavily biased presentation.

She added:

Most importantly though, there are several people in my year who aren’t heterosexual – myself included – and I for one was appalled and actually disgusted by what they were encouraging. After all, that’s discrimination they were urging impressionable people to engage in, which is unacceptable.

Numerous organisations including the British Humanist Association, the National Secular Society and SchoolsOut have indicated that the presentation could be in breach of multiple laws.

Greg Pope, the Deputy Director of the Catholic Education Service told Pink News:

We wrote to Catholic secondary schools to let them know of the archbishops’ letter on the government’s gay marriage proposals. We’ve asked them to draw attention generally to the Coalition for Marriage petition which is an open petition that people of all ages can sign. We have been aiming this towards older pupils and parents. The archbishop’s letter is a positive statement of the Church’s support for marriage, rather than negative comments about gay marriage.

The Coalition for Marriage themselves pointed out that the petition is not open to people “of all ages” as the Service suggested, but only to those aged 16 and above.

When alerted to this, Pope said that the Catholic Education Service would be clear in any future correspondence with schools that the Coalition for Marriage petition had an age restriction, but that it was not planning to contact schools again on the subject.

On the particular claims made by the student that the headmistress had called gay marriages “unnatural”, Pope conjured up these weasel words:

All pupils deserve to be treated with respect and tolerance. If a pupil or parent feels the school has not lived up to that, all schools have complaints procedures which meet the Department for Education requirements.

Conor Marron, who set up the Coalition for Equal Marriage to build grass roots support for equality and oppose the campaign of the Coalition for Marriage, told Pink News:

This is incredibly worrying.  These children are shamelessly being used and manipulated to further the goals of the religious right, most likely without the knowledge or permission of their parents.

With children as young as 11 being drawn into this without being adequately equipped with maturity and an understanding of the issues at hand is nothing less than abusive scaremongering.

He added:

They claim that one of their reasons to campaign against same-sex marriage is to try to protect children. This just goes to show how untrue that is, and that they will use any tool and stoop to any low to get what they want.They are the ones who are a threat to children, and this is a shining example as to the dangers of faith schools.

Sue Sanders, co-chair of Schools Out, told Pink News:

I hardly think telling people to sign a petition that limits LGB people their human rights is either appropriate or legal.

The Catholic Education Service said in response that the school is permitted by the Act to teach sex and relationship education in accordance with the teachings of the Catholic Church, but that it would not be allowed to discriminate or permit discrimination against pupils on the grounds of sexual orientation.

The Coalition for Marriage petition has attracted  over 467,000 signatures, while the Coalition for Equal Marriage has almost 49,000.

Hat tip: BarrieJohn

 

Hats off to Ray d’Arcy for standing his ground against the Catholic Church

IRISH radio host Ray D’Arcy  and self-proclaimed atheist has defied an ultimatum, issued by the Roman Catholic Church, to apologise for an attack he made on it on air.

Ray D'Arcy

The former children’s TV presenter told his 245,000 listeners that the Catholic Church had, in many ways, “fucked up this country”.

According to this report, he faced up to the fury of church leaders this week by telling his listeners on his Today FM show:

When I was referring to the Catholic Church, and I thought people would take this to be the case, I was referring to the hierarchy of the Catholic Church, not to people like my mother who is a devout Catholic and a great Christian.

He added:

I never meant to cause offence to them. And it is the hierarchy of the Catholic Church who have taken offence and are demanding an apology. That won’t be forthcoming. There won’t be a retraction. Because in my opinion the institution of the Catholic Church has caused well documented damage to the country and you don’t need me to go through the litany of the documented things they have perpetrated.

Ireland’s most popular presenter is now facing the prospect of being investigated by the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland (BAI).

The Communications Office of the Irish Bishops had demanded a full apology, and a spokesperson for the Church revealed at the weekend that the matter would be referred to the BAI in the form of a formal complaint unless an apology is made.

Catholic communications chief Martin Long, according to this report, demanded that the station and D’Arcy retract the “insulting” and “offensive” comment.

In a letter to station bosses, Long said:

Mr D’Arcy’s statement is grossly offensive and factually inaccurate. All those who hold the Catholic faith dear are deeply insulted by this appalling language.

By any objective or subjective measure, lay and religious members of the Catholic Church have and continue to contribute to the common good of our society, particularly in the areas of poverty, social justice, health and education.

He added:

In addition, it is shocking to hear such language on a national radio station at 9.15 on a school-day morning. I ask that an apology and a retraction be broadcast by the presenter at an equivalent time the next time the programme is broadcast, on Monday, 23 April.

Hat tip: Angela K and Glenn

Wacky Wiccans got naked and started indoor fires to see off ‘bad vibrations’

ON BALANCE, pagans are a much nicer class of people than, say, the joyless sourpusses who form the backbone of the Abrahamic religions. That’s not to say that they can’t be equally bloody stupid.

As part of a Wiccan-related ceremony, two Nottingham men got naked and started a fire indoors to rid the premises of negative vibes.

Mohammed Aftab Mughal, left and Terence Williams

This resulted in the pair – Mohammed Aftab Mughal, 21, and Terence Williams, 51 – having to be bundled in their birthday suits out of Williams’s house in Blair Court, The Meadows, by firemen, then later being charged with arson.

According to this report, Nottingham Crown Court was told how a neighbour became concerned after seeing thick smoke coming from the house.

When he looked inside, could see Williams standing next to a fire completely naked and throwing things on to it.

Siward James-Moore, prosecuting, said:

The flames were licking around Mr Williams’ ankles at that stage. Mr Williams was staring right through him.

The court heard the pair had been burning white sage leaves and a candle as they meditated. But when Mughal said there was a “negative vibe in the air”, they decided to burn it away with lit newspaper.

Said Mr James-Moore.

Terence Williams suggested both their clothes should be burnt to enhance the ritual they were undertaking. Fire crews were called to the property at around 11.50am on October 21. Firefighters entered the address and found two males within, these two defendants, both of them were completely naked. They initially refused to leave, were not concerned for their own safety and were shocked the fire service was called.

Williams, 51, described the daft goings-on as a Wiccan ceremony, involving burning items to cleanse their souls.

The court heard there had been three different fires in the house. There were two gas canisters in a cupboard, which were potentially a threat had the fire got out of control.

In sentencing the pair, who both men pleaded guilty to arson, to 12 months of community service, the judge, recorder Jason MacAdam, told them:

This fire was caused through stupidity rather than malice.

The judge noted both of them had done a great deal of good in their lives, and were:

Dedicated to doing good acts for people in the future.

Hat Tip: Gill Kerry

Muamba and the miracle-mongers … the saga continues

IN A thoroughly depressing display of stupidity and godly fervour, hordes of miracle-mongers came charging through a gate opened by the Sun yesterday with a report headed Fabrice Muamba: I asked God to protect me … he didn’t let me down.

The comments section of the report is laced with excruciating utterances of superstitious guff, typified by:

Every knee shall bow & every Tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is lord. Please Muamba tell us more about heaven.

This suggests that the writer believes that devout Christian Muamba spent more than an hour confabulating with God or Jesus (or both) while medics were trying to revive him after his heart stopped and he crashed unconscious to the pitch 41 minutes into the FA Cup tie at White Hart Lane earlier this year.

Mind you, buried in this mindless morass was one sane observation:

God bless the defibrillator and the skill of the medics who treated him.

The god that struck Muamba down, then revived him 78 minutes later, did so to prove his power, suggested Muamba’s dad, who is quoted as saying:

I said to God, ‘You are the one who resurrected Lazarus from the dead. Now in this moment glorify yourself’.

And his capricious god dutifully obliged …

King James Bible trumps the Canadian law, claims Canadian Christian crackpot

DOTTY minister Catherine Flamond, of the Church of the Ecumenical Redemption International, was none to pleased when she received three traffic tickets last year for driving without a licence plate or insurance, and failing to produce a driver’s licence.

What she calls her “ecclesiastical pursuit chariot” – a 1994 Mercury Sable – was ticketed in February, 2011, but Flamond, in a June 13 letter to Edmonton Police Chief Rod Knecht, claimed she had her own plate — made of paper and bearing the biblical verse Rom. 11:29:

For the gifts and calling of God are without repentance.

She then mounted a constitutional challenge against the tickets, arguing in a written Charter notice that the provincial civil laws do not apply to her because she is a Christian minister bound only by God, the Queen of England and the Constitution Act of 1982.

But this week Provincial Court Judge John Henderson tossed out her challenge, ruling that:

The Alberta Traffic Safety Act applies to “every single person” who operates a motor vehicle in the province.

Henderson also dismissed several other motions seeking to have the tickets quashed, including ones alleging wrongful prosecution and bias by the Crown and judge, who was also accused of coming close to treason.

The matter was then adjourned for trial on October 23.

In her Charter notice, Flamond included several letters she had written to people in authority.

She also called the car “church property” and accused the officer of stealing it and taking it to the “city pound.”

The Church of the Ecumenical Redemption International is a Christian denomination that does not believe in the authority of the Canadian government and wishes to use the King James Bible as the rule of law.

Flamond is by to means the only unhinged member of the church.  According to this report, in 2006 one of the congregation – Karen Ponto – had to be dragged kicking and screaming from Saskatoon provincial courtroom. She yelled at the judge that her arrest for contempt of court was a violation of her rights as a Christian.

Hat tip: Dog Gone

 

Nuns stunned after being ordered by the Vatican to get back on the straight and narrow

A LEADING American organisation of Catholic nuns – the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (LCWR) – has been severely rapped following a Vatican investigation which found that it was spending too much time on trivial issues such as poverty and social justice and not enough on raising hell over gay marriage and abortion.

The LCWR, which has around 1,500 members in the US,  says on its website that it was left stunned by the findings of Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF, formerly the Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Roman and Universal Inquisition. In 1981 a certain Joseph Ratzinger was appointed to head the Inquisition).

Pope Ratzinger once headed the Inquisition

The CDF said in its findings, published this week:

While there has been a great deal of work on the part of LCWR promoting issues of social justice in harmony with the Church’s social doctrine, it is silent on the right to life from conception to natural death … Further, issues of crucial importance in the life of the Church and society, such as the Church’s Biblical view of family life and human sexuality, are not part of the LCWR agenda in a way that promotes Church teaching.

The naughty nuns also stand accused of issuing occasional statements:

That disagree with or challenge positions taken by the Bishops, who are the Church’s authentic teachers of faith and morals.

The CDF thundered:

This is not compatible with its purpose.

And it pointed out:

The Assessment reveals serious doctrinal problems which affect many in Consecrated life …

In a sinister, Mafia-like move, the Vatican has called in a trio of “heavies” to knock the wayward nuns back into line. Archbishop Peter Sartain of Seattle has been named the CDF’s  “Archbishop Delegate” for the kick-ass initiative, assisted by Bishop Leonard Blair and Bishop Thomas John Paprocki.

It will be the task of the Archbishop Delegate to work collaboratively with the officers of the LCWR to achieve the goals outlined in this document, and to report on the progress of this to the Holy See …. In this way, the Holy See hopes to offer an important contribution to the future of religious life in the Church in the United States.

Hat tip: Robert Stovold

 

Faith-heads face manslaughter charges after choosing prayer over medical care

AUSTIN SPROUT was 16 when he died last December after his parents chose prayer, rather medical care for an undisclosed illness he was suffering.

Austin Sprout. Click on pic for video report

Five years earlier, the Oregon teenager’s fundamentalist dad, Brian Sprout, met his Maker after refusing medical treatment for sepsis that set in after an injury sustained in a fall.

Austin’s parents, Brandi and Russel Bellew, who attend General Assembly and the Church of the First Born in Pleasant Hill, Cresswell, now face second-degree manslaughter charges – and this week six of their children were made wards of the state. But they may continue to care for their remaining children under a state-supervised “in-home safety plan”,Lane County Circuit Juvenile Court Judge Eveleen Henry ruled in a brief afternoon hearing.

Terms of that plan include the presence of a state-approved “safety provider,” immediate notification of the state Department of Human Services if any of the children has “medical symptoms, illness or injury” and calling 911 if any medical emergency arises.

The safety monitor, Del McCracken, is a fellow church member, but “believes in seeking medical care and advocates for the children to have medical care,” the plan states.

The children are a blended family, created when Brandi and Russel Bellew married after both were widowed.

Brian Sprout was the biological father of three of the six children placed in state custody.

Monday’s hearing was packed with more than two dozen relatives and supporters of Brandi and Russel Bellew. Many were fellow church members who bowed their heads and appeared to pray during the hearing.

During the hearing lawyer, Bob Schrank, representing the Bellews, challenged as unnecessary the state’s request that both parents undergo a comprehensive psychological exam.

But child protection caseworker Jennifer Long Perkins said the state had a solid basis for seeking the exams:

By no means are we suggesting that these parents are crazy. But we are asking the family to make a significant, life-changing decision about a practice (faith-healing) they have long upheld. We want a professional opinion that they are able to do that.

Judge Henry ordered the exams, but allowed the couple to delay them until their criminal case is resolved.

Hat tip. Angela K

Norwich ‘hate-mongers’ banned from market stall

JUST days after it was reported the Irish-American actress and comedienne Rosie O’Donnell was targeted by a chauvinistic street preacher who called her a “lesbian pig” and told her to “go home and do the dishes, its your job” comes news from Norwich that a church has been barred from a market stall for disseminating “hate literature”.

Rosie O'Donnell faces up to a mad Christian fundie. Click on pic for video.

A complaint received by Norwich City Council about the stuff the Norwich Reformed Church was dishing out at a weekly “outreach” bookstall on the council-owned Hay Hill site prompted a review of the materials produced by the church’s pastor, Reverend Alan Clifford.

As a result, the council contacted police as the literature, particularly the leaflet entitled Why not Islam?, was considered to be “hate-motivated”.

The church was then told to bugger off and never darken the market again … or until such time someone decides it was all a horrible misunderstanding and that a gross infringement of freedom of expression had taken place.

The council-run Eaton Park Community Centre has also been contacted with a view to ceasing any further bookings made by the church.

A council spokesman said:

Although the police advised that no criminal offence had been committed, we have a duty under the Equality Act 2010 to foster good relations between people of all backgrounds and religions. By allowing premises owned by the council to be used by an organisation publishing such material, we would be failing in that duty. People across Norfolk have recently been urged to stand up to hate-motivated and intolerant behaviour through a publicity campaign and as a council we have to play our part and take action where necessary.

Clifford, who has scuttled off  to the Christian Institute for advice, said an “extraordinarily silly” form of “political correctness” had emerged.

While the opinion of the Christian Institute is awaited, it is hoped that in due course, common sense might prevail, and that Norwich Reformed Church’s rights to worship and witness will be restored.

 Hat tip: Angela Kingdom (O’Donnell report) and Agent Cormac

Church tax proposal: the bishops are revolting

ROMAN Catholic and C of E bishops in the UK have found something new to whinge about: a plan to impose VAT on  improvements made to cathedrals and churches.

According to this report, the bishops were “in revolt” over the scheme announced in the recent Budget.

The Most Reverend Vincent Nichols, the Archbishop of Westminster and leader of the Roman Catholic Church in England and Wales, said the move was “regrettable”:

Vincent Nichols

Nichols, who, courtesy of a certain Pope Ratzinger, came to his post in 2009 vowing to fight “an aggressively secular agenda”, added:

At a time of increasing austerity, it would be regrettable if they (listed churches) had to face higher costs for repairs and alterations from planned changes to VAT.

And the Right Reverend Christopher Chessun, warned that extending VAT to cover listed building improvements would:

Cause a great deal of difficulty for those caring for the nation’s heritage.

He added:

The extra costs this tax will impose on building projects, which enhance community and other use, will damage the ability of the church and others to undertake important work in building social cohesion.

Religion and social cohesion? Please tell me Chessun is having a laugh.

Meanwhile, the Bishop of London, the Right Reverend Richard Chartres, has written to Chancellor George Osborne urging him to exclude places of worship from the VAT extension or to boost a rebate scheme from which churches can reclaim spending on this tax.

The Treasury has pointed out that this grant scheme had been increased by £5 million to offset the VAT change.

But religious leaders have warned that the extra money will not fully cover the increased bill from having to pay VAT, at 20 per cent.

A Treasury spokesman said:

Currently listed places of worship, of any faith or denomination, can claim a grant equal to the VAT paid on eligible repairs and maintenance works. The scheme will be extended to include approved alterations to listed places of worship.

Hat tip: Pax Tayer

 

Another preacher jumps ship

FOLLOWING the news earlier this month that Teresa MacBain, pastor at Lake Jackson Methodist Church had resigned her post to join American Atheists comes a report from Australia that another preacher has used an atheist conference to public declare the end of a lengthy involvement with Christianity.

According to Recovering From Religion, Jerry deWitt – now its Executive Director – became a non-believer after more than 25 years of Pentecostal ministry in his home state of Louisiana. His “coming out” cost him his job, and almost hishome, but he could not be happier because he feels he has regained his integrity.

Jerry deWitt saw the light and ditched Christianity

DeWitt said he could not abide the hypocrisy of the pulpit. His story emerged at the Global Atheist Convention in Melbourne through his friend and fellow former pastor, Dan Barker, founder of an online support group for clergy who have lost their faith.

The international group, including at least one Australian and a former imam, has grown to more than 200 members in its first year. Most have left their jobs, but more than 50 are still active clergy, Mr Barker says. The group, The Clergy Project, is getting up to 40 applications a month, each of which is carefully vetted by volunteer screeners to make sure it is genuine.

Said Barker

It’s a sanctuary, where they feel they can hold on to their sanity.

Funded by the Richard Dawkins Foundation, the support group has several forums, all of which are confined to members.

Barker, founder of the Freedom from Religion Foundation, left the ministry in 1984 after 19 years as a preacher.

Leading philosopher Daniel Dennett said the mismatch between what the clergy believed and what their parishioners expected them to believe was a source of real anguish.

One told me, if you offered retraining you’d have 10,000 members tomorrow.

Dennett has led a study involving several of the clergy.

Christian leaders know it is true. Hardly anyone denies it is a phenomenon, but no one knows how big it is. They are like gays in the 1950s, but without gaydar.

He said these ministers were caught in ”an insidious trap baited with goodness”, but it caused most of them real suffering.

Lord Carey’s loses the plot – completely!

HOMOSEXUAL “activists” – in a mythical land inhabited by former Archbishop of Canterbury, Lord George Carey – are in the vanguard of a sustained and vicious campaign to vilify Christians and drive them underground.

Lord George Carey

In a submission to the European Court of Human Rights in support of a clot of “persecuted” religious fanatics who proved unfit for purpose in their respective jobs and were rightly dismissed, Cary writes that Christians can be sacked for manifesting their faith, are vilified by state bodies, are in fear of reprisal and can even be arrested for expressing their views on sexual ethics. All of this:

Affects the moral and ethical compass of the United Kingdom. Christians are excluded from many sectors of employment simply because of their beliefs; beliefs which are not contrary to the public good … It is now Christians who are persecuted; often sought out and framed by homosexual activists.

Christians are driven underground. There appears to be a clear animus to the Christian faith and to Judeo-Christian values. Clearly the courts of the United Kingdom need guidance.

Carey’s hope that his latest bleat would result in outpouring of sympathy, or even vigorous nods of agreement were dashed when commentators immediately set about exposing him as paranoid loon with a very tenuous grip on reality.

This, from Guardian columnist Martin Robbins:

In his latest outburst, Carey is guilty of at least three sins against his flock: he fear-mongers regarding the ability of Christians to express their faith in public, he regurgitates a slew of mythical episodes of Christian persecution, and he entirely misrepresents secularism.

Robbins then points out that Carey can hardly claim that “the outward expression of traditional conservative Christian values has effectively been ‘banned” in Britain’ when, as a life peer, he:

Lives in a palace, holds a seat in the House of Lords (alongside twenty-odd other Bishops from the Church of England), and has his remarks published on the front pages of newspapers.

Ophelia Benson, over at Butterflies and Wheels makes pretty much the same point – then dismisses him in two words:

Filthy man.

And Executive Director of the National Secular Society, Keith Porteous Wood said:

Lord Carey is not just wrong, but the truth is the opposite of what he asserts. Far from the UK being less intolerant than the rest of the world on religion, it is perhaps the most religiously tolerant country in the world.

Hat tip: Marcus Robinson

Don’t mess with the miracle-mongers, for they shall smite thee mightily with the law

RATIONALISTS in India have a long and admirable history of exposing religious frauds, hucksters and other charlatans. Foremost among these miracle-busters is Sanal Edamaruku, President of the Rationalist International organisation, whose latest exposé may see him arrested at any moment on a “blasphemy” charge.

A water drop is shown forming on toe of the drippy Jesus (click on image for video)

In this case, all Edamaruku did was to demonstrate that there was nothing miraculous about the water dripping from the feet of Jesus, on a cross at the Church of Our Lady of Velankanni.

The cross, according to this report, had become the centre of attraction for an ever-growing crowd of believers. Hundreds came every day to pray and collect some of the “holy water” in bottles and vessels.

Sanal Edamaruku travelled to the church with a TV crew, identified the source of the water (drainage near a washing room) and he demonstrated the simple mechanism – capillary action – by which it reached Jesus’ feet.

Some hours later, in a live programme on TV-9, Sanal explained his findings and accused Catholic Church officials of miracle mongering. They had been clearly milking the drippy Jesus to the max with an aggressive PR push.

Click on image for the debate

A heated debate ensued, in which five church personnel and representatives of the Association of Concerned Catholics (AOCC) demanded that Sanal apologise. He refused and argued against them.

They then threatened to file a blasphemy charge against him – and they did.

On April 10 he received a phone call from a Police official at Juhu Police Station in Mumbai ordering him to the station to face the charges. Edamaruku also revealed that FIRs (First Information Reports prepared by the police when they receive information about the commission of an offence) have also been filed in Andheri and other police stations under Section 295 of the Indian Penal Code. These are apparently based on allegations that his exposé  had hurt Catholics’ “religious sentiments”.

N D Pancholi, Convenor of the  Sanal Edamaruku Defence Committee, said in a statement:

It is distressing that the Mumbai police has chosen to harass and victimise him for doing his fundamental duty. The Sanal Edamaruku Defence Committee appeals to all progressive individuals and organisations to protest and oppose the reprehensible steps of the Maharashtra police in filing FIRs against Sanal and stand behind him in solidarity for the cause of scientific thinking and freedom of expression.

 Hat tip: Zé Fontainhas

Spanish baby-trafficking scandal: elderly nun refuses to testify

A NUN in her 80s – the first person to be charged after an investigation by the authorities into Spain’s “stolen babies” scandal that lasted decades – this week refused to testify in a Madrid court.

Sister Maria Gomez Valbuena. Pedro Armestre / AFP - Getty Images

Sister Maria Gomez Valbuena is facing charges related to her alleged role in a baby-trafficking network of clerics and doctors that operated in Spain from the 1940s until the early 1990s. Children were taken from their parents and sold to other couples.

More than a thousand cases have been filed with Spain’s attorney general.

During her court appearance on Thursday, crowds of mothers claiming their newborns were stolen reportedly chanted, “shameless” at the nun. Shortly after refusing to testify, the nun issued a statement denying the allegations.

Under no circumstance have I ever had any knowledge of the separation of a newborn from his or her biological mother under force and threats. It disgusts me to the depths of my being. I consider it inadmissible and unjustifiable.

Meanwhile, police documents published in Australia implicate the Catholic Church  in the suicides of at least 40 people who were sexually abused by priests in Victoria.

The reports, written by Detective Sergeant Kevin Carson, allege that the Church appears to have known about a shockingly high rate of suicides and premature deaths but has chosen to remain silent.

They linked the suicides to the sexual abuse perpetrated by a band of paedophile clergy, including Gerard Ridsdale, Bryan Coffey, Paul Ryan, Robert Best and Edward Dowlan. Most of the victims were abused between the 1960s and late 1980s.

One of the reports says it would appear an investigation would uncover many more deaths as a consequence of clergy sexual abuse.

Det-Sgt Carson wrote that at the end of last year that the sheer number of young men who were abused or suspected to be the victims or abuse, and who had met a premature death, continued to grow.

A spokesman for the Melbourne Catholic Archdiocese claimed that the only information it has about such suicides is what has appeared in the media.

We don’t have access to any information that links suicides with sexual abuse.

Victims and their relatives have called on Premier Ted Baillieu and Attorney-General Robert Clark to create an inquiry with royal commission powers to examine sexual abuse involving religious organisations.

The wheels come off crazy Christian’s ‘Gay cure’ London bus ad campaign

DOWNRIGHT dangerous, discredited, stupid and irresponsible. That’s the only way of describing persistent attempts by fundamentalist groups to change human sexual orientation. Well, to change gay people “straight”, to be more precise.

Just days after the Melbourne’s Sunday Age carried a damning expose of “reparative” treatments to Australian homosexuals, it was announced that London buses would be carrying ads advocating gay cures. Behind the ad campaign were two crackpot outfits: the Core Issues Trust (motto: God’s heart in sexual and relational brokenness …) whose leader, Mike Davidson, believes “homoerotic behaviour is sinful”, and Anglican Mainstream, a worldwide orthodox Anglican group whose supporters have equated homosexuality with alcoholism. The advert was due to say:

Not gay! Post-gay, ex-gay and proud. Get over it!

Such was the outrage that to the planned campaign that London Mayor, Boris Johnson immediately crushed it.

Johnson, who contacted the Guardian to announce he was stopping the adverts within two hours of their contents becoming public, said:

London is one of the most tolerant cities in the world and intolerant of intolerance. It is clearly offensive to suggest that being gay is an illness that someone recovers from and I am not prepared to have that suggestion driven around London on our buses.

His main rival in next month’s mayoral election, Ken Livingstone, said Johnson should never have allowed the adverts to be booked.

London is going backwards under a Tory leadership that should have made these advertisements impossible. They promote a falsehood, the homophobic idea of ‘therapy’ to change the sexual orientation of lesbians and gay men.

The campaign was an explicit attempt to hit back at the gay rights group Stonewall, which as part of its lobbying for the extension of marriage to gay couples is running its own bus adverts saying:

Some people are gay. Get over it.

The Christian groups used the same black, red and white colour scheme as Stonewall and in a statement announcing the campaign accused it of promoting:

The false idea that there is indisputable scientific evidence that people are born gay.

The gay ex-vicar, Labour MP and former minister Chris Bryant, said the advert was cruel for promoting the idea that you could become “ex-gay” and he said it would particularly hurt teenagers struggling to come to terms with their sexuality.

The emotional damage that is done to the individuals who try to suppress their sexuality, the women they marry and the children they might have is immeasurable. Most sane Christians believe that homosexuality is not a lifestyle or a choice but is a fact to be discovered or not. The pretence that homosexuality is something you can be weaned off in some way is a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of creation.

Ben Summerskill, the chief executive of Stonewall, said the adverts were “clearly homophobic” and added:

The only reason some gay people might want to stop being gay is because of the prejudice of the people who are publishing the ad. The promotion of this voodoo therapy is hugely irresponsible given the damage that it appears to do to some people.

Both men said the advert should not be banned, however, because they believed in freedom of speech.

Attempts to “treat” or alter sexual orientation have been strongly condemned by leading medical organisations. The Royal College of Psychiatrists has warned that “so-called treatments of homosexuality create a setting in which prejudice and discrimination flourish” and concluded in 2010:

There is no sound evidence that sexual orientation can be changed.

The dotty Rev Lynda Rose, a spokesperson for the UK branch of Anglican Mainstream, said her group adhered to scripture that all fornication outside marriage is prohibited and believed that homosexuals were:

Not being fully the people God intended us to be.

She said therapies endorsed by Anglican Mainstream and Core Issues were not coercive and were appropriate for people who wanted to change their sexual attractions, for example if they were married and worried about the impact of a “gay lifestyle” on their children.

Hat tip: Remigius and BarrieJohn