Monthly Archive for April, 2007Page 2 of 2

In defense of the problem of evil

The existence of unnecessary suffering in the face of an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God, the problem of evil, has remained a primary logical objection against Christianity for ages.

Although no philosophical argument can completely disprove God, it can prove our current definition logically impossible. The “evidential problem of evil” is rather simple:

  1. Gratuitous evils exist.
  2. Gratuitous evils are incompatible with the existence of a god (omnipotent, omniscient, all-good).
  3. Therefore, no god exists.

The textbook apologetic dodge varies. Some Christians will adjust their definition to invent a not-completely omnipotent god. Others will blame Satan, creating a second god, and begging the question: why hasn’t God eliminated him? Others still see suffering as a means to spiritual strength, ignoring the fact noble, character shaping acts can be done in the absence of pain.

More, however, will assert God gives humans the choice to commit bad deeds, blaming the fall of Adam. Though this defense tries to explain evil committed by humans it does nothing to justify “acts of God” or natural phenomena that lead to unnecessary suffering. Even if natural events are placed into the same boat, we must address the unnecessary suffering they have caused millions of years before human even walked the earth.

Another interesting objection questions why a god who values free will would create humans, a species dependent on sleep, knowing we waste approximately a third of our life in bed, incapable of making choices.

Like the existence of suffering in general, the idea of sin leading to suffering is still inconsistent with an all-loving god.


Matzo Lab Bust / The 50-Foot Robot King of Pop

Looking back over the past few posts, I realize that I've been harping on some pretty heavy shit. First Ladies dying in the White House, smokers snuffing it before they can collect their pensions, families of slain police officers viewing graphic simulations of police officer slayings, racist tribal elections, Iraq . . . It's as though I had forgotten that the world is still, at base, a Zippy the Pinhead comic full of carefree aesthetic delights, free to be savored by all takers. In order to restore some balance, I would like to bring two items to your attention.

First, inspectors in Spring Valley, New York recently busted an illicit backyard matzo lab operating out of a converted school bus. Rabbi Aaron Winternitz had been running the operation for the last three Passovers, ever since he bought the derelict vehicle and installed an oven, a human-powered wheat mill fashioned from a stationary bicycle, and, more problematically, an unauthorized gas line from his house. The purpose of the gas line is unclear, since the matzo oven itself is wood-fired--as attested to by the shoulder-high stack of firewood surrounding the vehicle.

Not surprisingly, local officials found the combination of a massive open-flame oven, stacks of combustible wood and dried wheat, and do-it-yourself natural gas fittings problematic when operating 10 feet from a residential structure. Spring Valley matzo futures no doubt traded up on news of the reduced supply; at peak production, the bus was capable of turning out 100 lbs of product per day.

Second, Michael Jackson has announced plans to build a 50-foot robotic effigy of himself in Las Vegas. According to press reports, the device will wander through the surrounding deserts shooting laser beams out of its eyeballs. This is all fine and good, but I know where I'm not taking my 50-foot robot twelve-year-old boy.